The 5200 earns the top slot by being the least clever machine here. A 2 HP motor drives a laser-cut stainless blade at the bottom of a tall, narrow 64 ounce jar, and that tall geometry is exactly what thick paste needs, because the tamper can be pushed down through the lid plug to reach the blades while the motor keeps turning. There is no preset to second-guess: you turn the dial up, flip to high and let friction do the work.
The tradeoff is the tall jar. It stands taller than the Propel 750's low-profile container, so it does not slide under many standard cabinets, and the dial gives you no timer or program memory. For a first batch of roasted almonds expect to stop and re-seat the tamper several times as the nuts turn from crumb to paste. Even this base has a thermal cutout, so keep the load near two cups of nuts rather than filling the jar.
Ownership is simple. The jar and blade assembly come apart only at the factory-sealed base of the blade, so cleaning is a warm water and dish soap run right after you pour out the butter, before the oil sets. Nut butter residue is oily, so a second hot rinse beats a dry wipe, and the jar lid plug should be pulled and washed because it traps paste.
What works
- Tall jar and tamper keep dense paste circulating
- 2 HP base has headroom for oily loads
- Plain dial gives full control at top speed
- Wide jar mouth is easy to scrape clean
Watch out for
- Tall jar will not fit under many cabinets
- No timer or preset so you must watch the batch
- Needs a quick rinse before oil hardens
Spec sheet
- Motor
- 2 HP
- Jar
- 64 oz classic tall
- Controls
- Dial plus high/low switch
- Tamper
- Included
- Blades
- Laser-cut stainless





