Amazon affiliate links - we earn a commission.Affiliate disclosure

Buying guide · 13 min read · Updated 2026-11-19

Best Frigidaire Countertop Ice Makers (2026)

Six Frigidaire countertop ice makers compared: bullet and square-cube models at 26 lb and nugget machines at 33 and 44 lb, with size, speed and upkeep notes.

James MillerBy James MillerLead Machine Editor6 machines comparedSpec-sheet verified
Best Frigidaire Countertop Ice Makers

At a glance

Our top picks

Side by side

Spec comparison

One major appliance brand's countertop range covers three different mechanisms under one name. A bullet unit freezes ice on chilled prongs, a square-cube unit freezes water in a tray, and a nugget unit scrapes a frozen cylinder with an auger. They look similar on a counter and behave very differently in use.

Brand familiarity matters most for after-sale support, parts and the confidence that a manual and a service line exist. Within the brand we compare the machines on ice type, output, speed, size and the cleaning they need, then rank who each one suits.

Before you buy

6 Criteria to Look For Before Buying a Frigidaire Countertop Ice Maker

  1. 01

    Bullet, square-cube or nugget

    Frigidaire's countertop range spans three ice types. Bullet makers like the EFIC128 and the black stainless unit freeze hard cubes quickly. The EFIC189 freezes square cubes that melt slower. The Gallery and EFIC228 nugget models make soft chewable pellets with an auger. Decide the ice first, since none can switch.

  2. 02

    Output and basket size

    Daily output runs from 26 pounds on the bullet and cube models to 33 and 44 on the nugget models. The EFIC189 stores about 2.2 pounds in its basket, and the others hold a similar amount before pausing. For a busy household, a pause is the limiting factor, not the daily rating.

  3. 03

    Cleaning and scale

    The Gallery and touchscreen nugget models have automatic cleaning cycles, with the touchscreen model finishing in about 20 minutes. None of the machines removes mineral scale automatically. A monthly or bimonthly descale with citric acid is the real maintenance.

  4. 04

    Noise and placement

    Nugget machines run an auger and a compressor, so they are louder than bullet and cube makers. Place the machine on a solid counter with several inches of clearance, away from a bedroom wall. A cabinet that traps heat raises noise and cuts output. If you plan to run a nugget machine under a cabinet, leave an open front and a gap at the back so the compressor can exhale, and test it for a day before you decide the spot works.

  5. 05

    Size and fit

    Nugget machines are taller than bullet makers, and Frigidaire says the Gallery fits under cabinets. Bullet units like the EFIC128 are compact enough for a small counter or a camper. Measure your space and check the dimensions against the listing before ordering. Allow for the clearance the maker specifies around the vents, usually several inches, as well as the height needed to lift a lid or pull out a drawer.

  6. 06

    Brand support

    A major appliance brand means a manual, a service line and parts that are easier to find than from a no-name seller. That matters most in year three, when a pump or a sensor fails. Weigh the extra cost of a known brand against how much you depend on the machine. Check the warranty length and the claim process before you buy, and keep your receipt, since a countertop appliance is cheap enough that many owners skip registration and regret it later.

Detailed reviews

The 6 best frigidaire countertop ice makers, explained

01
Frigidaire Gallery countertop nugget ice maker, 44 lb, cream, touch panel
44 lb per dayNugget iceTouch panelViewing window
Check price on Amazon
Best for: Homes that want a high-output chewable-ice machine from a major brand.

The Gallery's nugget design scrapes ice from a cold cylinder with an auger and presses it into soft, crunchy pellets, and at 44 pounds a day it is the highest-output Frigidaire countertop machine. Touch buttons control it, and a drawer with a viewing window shows how full the bin is without opening anything.

Frigidaire calls it compact enough to fit under cabinets, which matters because nugget machines are tall. Auto self-cleaning handles routine flushing, though scale on the cylinder still needs a periodic descale. The cream finish is a styling choice that stands out in a kitchen.

Against the 33 lb nugget models it makes a third more ice. Place it with vent clearance, descale every month or two and keep an eye on the bin through the window.

What works

  • 44 lb per day is the top Frigidaire countertop output
  • Drawer and viewing window show ice level
  • Touch panel and auto self-cleaning
  • Compact enough for under-cabinet use

Watch out for

  • Nugget machines are louder than bullet units
  • Cream finish may not suit every kitchen

Spec sheet

Daily output
44 lb
Ice type
Crunchy chewable nugget
Control
Touch panel
Access
Drawer with viewing window
Cleaning
Auto self-cleaning
02
Frigidaire touchscreen nugget ice maker, 33 lb, slate, 20 min self-clean
33 lb per dayTouchscreenSonic nugget20 min clean
Check price on Amazon
Best for: Owners who want an easy, quick self-cleaning cycle.

A touchscreen replaces the buttons on this Frigidaire, and the headline convenience is an automatic cleaning cycle that completes in about 20 minutes. For a machine that most owners neglect, a short cycle is a real reason it will actually get run.

Daily output reaches 33 pounds of light, crunchy nugget ice that blends into drinks and absorbs their flavor. The slate finish suits modern kitchens. Like every nugget machine it is heavier and louder than a bullet unit, and the cleaning cycle flushes but does not descale.

Compared with the Gallery 44 lb it makes less and adds a screen and a faster clean. Descale on schedule, keep vent clearance and let the machine dry if it will sit idle.

What works

  • Touchscreen control
  • Automatic cleaning cycle in about 20 minutes
  • Up to 33 lb per day
  • Soft chewable nugget ice

Watch out for

  • Output is a third lower than the 44 lb Gallery
  • Cleaning cycle does not remove scale

Spec sheet

Daily output
Up to 33 lb
Ice type
Soft chewable nugget
Control
Touchscreen
Cleaning
Automatic cycle in 20 minutes
Finish
Slate
03
Frigidaire EFIC228 countertop nugget ice maker, 33 lb, compact, metallic
33 lb per day15 min first iceCompactMetallic finish
Check price on Amazon
Best for: Shoppers who want Frigidaire nugget ice at the lowest price.

The EFIC228 is the straightforward nugget machine in the range: 33 pounds a day, soft crunchy ice and a compact countertop body in a metallic finish. The maker claims you will be enjoying ice within about 15 minutes, a slower start than newer nugget makers but a fair figure for a first batch.

It plugs into any outlet and is light enough to take to a campsite. The trade-off is feature count: there is no touchscreen and no fast cleaning cycle, so it is simpler and cheaper. Nugget ice here is the same as in the pricier models.

Compared with the touchscreen model it is plainer and slower to start. Descale regularly, keep vents clear and wipe the bin every couple of weeks.

What works

  • Soft crunchy nugget ice
  • 33 lb per day
  • Compact and portable
  • Simple design with fewer electronics

Watch out for

  • 15 minute start is slower than newer models
  • No touchscreen or fast clean cycle

Spec sheet

Daily output
33 lb
First ice
About 15 minutes
Ice type
Soft crunchy nugget
Size
Compact countertop
Portability
Plugs into any outlet
04
Frigidaire EFIC189 compact ice maker, 26 lb, two cube sizes, silver
26 lb per dayUnder 6 min2.2 lb basket2 cube sizes
Check price on Amazon
Best for: Cocktail and drink fans who want slow-melting square cubes.

This model makes square, clear cubes instead of bullets, in under six minutes per batch, with a choice of two cube sizes. The reservoir sits beneath the ice basket, a layout that keeps the footprint small, and the basket stores up to about 2.2 pounds before the machine pauses.

Square cubes melt slower than bullets and look better in a glass, a plus for cocktails and display. Output is 26 pounds a day, the same as the bullet models. Nothing here is automated beyond the basics, so it is a simple, durable machine.

Compared with the black bullet model it adds a cube-shape and size choice at the same output. Clean the reservoir regularly, descale every month or two and let the machine dry if it will be idle.

What works

  • Square clear cubes melt slower than bullets
  • Two cube sizes
  • Cycle in under 6 minutes
  • Stores about 2.2 lb

Watch out for

  • 26 lb per day is modest
  • Small basket pauses production quickly

Spec sheet

Daily output
26 lb
Cycle
Under 6 minutes
Storage
Up to 2.2 lb
Cube sizes
Two
Reservoir
Beneath the ice basket
05
Frigidaire 26 lb portable bullet ice maker, black stainless steel
26 lb per day9 cubes per cycleAbout 7 minViewing window
Check price on Amazon
Best for: Everyday ice with a familiar brand and a simple interface.

This is the machine most people picture when they think of a Frigidaire countertop ice maker: a compact portable unit that makes nine bullet cubes about every seven minutes, up to 26 pounds a day, in a black stainless steel body. A transparent window lets you see the ice level and the batch forming.

Bullet ice is hard and quick to make, with a pointed shape that packs a cooler well. The seven minute cycle is slower than the six-minute claims of some newer machines, and the basket stops the machine when it fills. As with all bullet makers, melted ice drains back to the reservoir, so stored ice shrinks.

Compared with the EFIC189 it makes bullets instead of squares. Keep the vents clear, descale monthly and dry the machine if it will sit.

What works

  • Nine bullet cubes about every seven minutes
  • Transparent window shows ice level
  • Black stainless steel finish
  • Simple controls

Watch out for

  • Stored ice melts back into the reservoir
  • 7 minute cycle is not the fastest

Spec sheet

Daily output
26 lb
Batch
9 bullet cubes about every 7 minutes
Window
Transparent, shows ice level
Finish
Black stainless steel
Type
Portable bullet
06
Frigidaire EFIC128 compact countertop ice maker, 26 lb, black, large window
26 lb per dayCompactLarge windowBlack
Check price on Amazon
Best for: Small counters and campers that want a simple compact unit.

The EFIC128 is the compact, modern take on the bullet maker, with a large transparent window so you can watch ice form and see the level. Daily output is 26 pounds, the same as as the other Frigidaire bullet models, in a small black body.

Frigidaire pitches it for a wide range of uses because of its small size, from a kitchen counter to a camper. The window is the main usability feature, as a full basket pauses production and you can see it. Like all bullet makers it is quick, cheap and loses stored ice to melting.

Compared with the black stainless bullet model it is smaller with a bigger window. Check the dimensions against your space, descale regularly and keep vent clearance.

What works

  • Large transparent window
  • Compact modern body
  • 26 lb per day
  • Simple operation

Watch out for

  • Stored ice melts back into the reservoir
  • Output is modest for a busy household

Spec sheet

Daily output
26 lb
Design
Modern with a large transparent window
Size
Compact countertop
Finish
Black
Ice type
Bullet cubes

Spec sheet decoder

What the numbers on the box really mean

The specs manufacturers lead with, translated into what they tell you about real-world performance.

Nugget ice

Soft pellets made by scraping and compressing a frozen cylinder. They are chewable and flavor-absorbing.

Watch forThree of the six Frigidaire machines here make nugget ice.

Lbs per day

A daily output rating in a cool room. Real output is lower in a warm kitchen.

Watch forThe Gallery claims 44 lb; the bullet and cube units claim 26 lb.

Basket capacity

How much ice the basket holds before the machine stops making more.

Watch forThe EFIC189 stores up to about 2.2 lb.

Self-cleaning cycle

An automatic flush of the reservoir and lines. It does not remove mineral scale.

Watch forThe touchscreen model's cycle takes about 20 minutes.

Cube sizes

A choice between thinner and thicker cubes to suit different drinks.

Watch forThe EFIC189 offers two sizes.

Methodology

How We Evaluated These Frigidaire Countertop Ice Makers

Ice type fit

We ranked each machine within its own ice type. The Gallery led nugget machines, the EFIC189 led cubes and the black stainless model led bullets. We did not compare across types.

Output and storage

We looked at daily output from 26 to 44 pounds and the basket capacity of about 2.2 pounds on the EFIC189. A pause when the basket fills limits party use. Output claims were treated as best-case.

Cleaning features

We compared the Gallery's auto cleaning and the touchscreen model's 20 minute cycle with the plainer models. Faster cleaning scored higher. None removes scale, which we noted for all.

Noise and size

We considered auger noise, body height and fit under cabinets. Bullet units scored for quiet and compactness. Nugget models scored for ice quality.

Support

We credited the Frigidaire brand for manuals and service. We noted that a major brand does not replace regular descaling. Simpler models scored for fewer parts to fail.

Decision guide

How to Choose the Right Frigidaire Countertop Ice Makers

By Ice Type

SituationPickWhy
Chewable nugget, high outputFrigidaire Gallery 44 lbHighest output
Chewable nugget, easy cleaningFrigidaire touchscreen 33 lb20 minute clean
Slow-melting square cubesFrigidaire EFIC189Two cube sizes
Plain bullet cubesFrigidaire 26 lb black stainlessClassic design

By Budget

SituationPickWhy
Lowest outlayFrigidaire EFIC128Compact bullet
Low outlay, cubesFrigidaire EFIC189Square cubes
Mid-range nuggetFrigidaire EFIC228Plain 33 lb nugget
PremiumFrigidaire Gallery 44 lbTop output

Nugget vs Bullet

Nugget

The Gallery, touchscreen and EFIC228 make soft chewable pellets. They are taller, louder and pricier.

Bullet and cube

The EFIC128, black stainless and EFIC189 make hard cubes quickly. They are lighter, quieter and cheaper.

Nugget for chewing and flavor; bullet or cube for speed and price.

Ease of Cleaning

SituationPickWhy
Fastest clean cycleFrigidaire touchscreen 33 lbAbout 20 minutes
Auto-clean on a big machineFrigidaire Gallery 44 lbAuto self-cleaning
See the bin without openingFrigidaire EFIC128Large window
Basic wipe-downFrigidaire 26 lb black stainlessSimple reservoir

For Small Kitchens Specifically

Look for

A compact body, a window to check the ice level and a design that fits under cabinets.

In this comparison

The EFIC128 is the smallest. The Gallery claims it fits under cabinets despite being a nugget machine.

When to Spend More

Spend more if

You want chewable ice daily or a quick clean routine. The Gallery and touchscreen models repay.

Save if

You want plain cubes occasionally. The EFIC128 or the black stainless model is enough.

Ownership

Maintenance schedule

The upkeep that decides whether this machine lasts two seasons or ten.

TaskIntervalWhy it matters
Descale the evaporator or cylinderEvery 1 to 2 monthsScale cuts output and clouds the ice. Run a citric acid cycle or Frigidaire's recommended cleaner through the reservoir to clear it.
Run the self-cleaning cycleEvery 2 weeksIt flushes the reservoir of residue. It slows biofilm but does not replace descaling, and on the plainer models it is the only built-in help you get, so schedule it rather than waiting for a smell.
Wipe the bin and windowEvery 2 weeksA damp bin grows film, and a cloudy window hides the ice level. A soft cloth with a drop of mild cleaner and a rinse is enough, and avoid abrasive pads that scratch the window and leave rough spots where scale gathers.
Clear ventsMonthlyWhen dust clogs the rear vents of a Frigidaire countertop unit, the compressor runs hotter and daily output drops. A soft brush on the grille and a few inches of space on every side keep the compressor cool and quiet, and cost nothing to maintain.
Dry the machine when idleBefore storageStanding water grows slime. Drain the reservoir, wipe it dry and leave the lid open, so the next time you power up after a long gap the machine starts clean and does not need an extra flush.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Frigidaire countertop ice maker makes the most ice?

The Gallery nugget model claims 44 pounds a day. The touchscreen and EFIC228 nugget models claim 33, and the bullet and cube models claim 26. Real output is lower in a warm room. In a hot kitchen with warm tap water, a 26 pound machine may deliver closer to twenty, so size your expectation to your conditions and not to the label.

Is nugget ice worth the extra cost?

If you like chewable ice that absorbs flavor, yes. Nugget machines cost more, run louder and weigh more than bullet makers. They also need more attention to scale, because the auger and cylinder are the heart of the machine, so budget a little time each month for descaling.

Does the self-cleaning cycle remove scale?

No. It flushes the reservoir but not mineral buildup. Descale with citric acid or a maker-approved cleaner every month or two. After descaling, run a couple of clean-water cycles and discard the first ice, since leftover descaler gives the ice an off taste that is easy to mistake for a bad machine.

How much ice does the basket hold?

About 2.2 pounds on the EFIC189, and a similar amount on the others. When it is full the machine stops, so bag the ice if you need more. For a gathering, empty the basket into a freezer bag every hour, which keeps the machine producing and keeps the ice from melting back into the reservoir.

Do these machines keep ice frozen?

No. Stored ice slowly melts into the reservoir below, so the pile in the basket shrinks if left alone. Use it fresh or bag and freeze it. The machine is a producer, not a storage unit, so think of it as a faucet for ice that you fill into something else rather than a freezer on the counter.

Can I use these in an RV?

Yes, they plug into a standard outlet and are portable. Let a moved machine stand upright for a few hours before powering on. A camper counter is often small and warm, so check the clearance and keep the machine out of direct sun, because heat is what slows a compressor most.

Bottom line

The short version

Browse more frigidaire countertop ice makerson Amazon →
James Miller, Lead Machine Editor

About the author

James Miller

Lead Machine Editor, MachineFanatic

James Miller leads MachineFanatic's buying guides, turning spec sheets, manuals and owner feedback into clear verdicts on power tools, outdoor power equipment, shop machines and kitchen machines.

More from James →

Keep reading

Related guides