Amazon affiliate links - we earn a commission.Affiliate disclosure

Buying guide · 12 min read · Updated 2026-11-19

Best Frigidaire Nugget Ice Makers (2026)

Four Frigidaire nugget ice makers compared: the Gallery, a touchscreen model and two compact 33 lb units, with first-ice time, cleaning and build differences.

James MillerBy James MillerLead Machine Editor5 machines comparedSpec-sheet verified
Best Frigidaire Nugget Ice Makers

At a glance

Our top picks

Side by side

Spec comparison

Nugget ice has a following for a reason. The soft, airy pellets are easy to chew, cool a drink fast and soak up the flavor of whatever they sit in. A countertop machine makes them by freezing a thin layer onto a chilled cylinder and scraping it off with a slowly turning auger.

That mechanism sets the buying questions. How quickly does the first ice arrive, how thorough is the cleaning routine, how big is the body and how much noise comes with it? Within one brand's nugget range the differences are subtle, so we compare the four machines on those points and on what each one asks of you over a year.

Before you buy

6 Criteria to Look For Before Buying a Frigidaire Nugget Ice Maker

  1. 01

    First-ice time

    Claims range from about 10 to 15 minutes on the EFIC144 to within about 15 minutes on the EFIC228. These are cold-start figures. After the first batch the machine makes ice at a steady pace of roughly a pound or so an hour, so a faster start is a convenience and not a sign of higher daily output. If you use ice spontaneously, the start time matters; if you use it steadily, it does not.

  2. 02

    Cleaning cycle and effort

    The touchscreen model's automatic cycle takes about 20 minutes, and the Gallery has an auto self-cleaning function. A cycle that is easy to start gets run, while a hard routine gets skipped. None of the four removes mineral scale, so a descale with citric acid every month or two is still your job. The flush cycle slows biofilm, the descale protects the auger.

  3. 03

    Body, build and fit

    Nugget machines are taller and heavier than bullet units, and the Gallery lists stainless materials and asks buyers to check dimensions. A heavier machine can be a pain to move, so choose a permanent spot. Measure the height under your cabinets and the clearance around the vents before ordering.

  4. 04

    Noise and placement

    An auger adds a grinding sound to the compressor hum, which is why nugget machines are louder than bullet makers. Place the unit away from a bedroom wall or a quiet reading corner. Hard counters carry vibration, so a rubber mat can help. A cabinet that traps heat raises noise and cuts output. If you must put it under a cabinet, check that the front and back stay open and that nothing sits against the vents.

  5. 05

    Output expectations

    Four machines claim up to 33 pounds a day and the Gallery Smart claims 44, which is a best-case number in a cool room with cold water. A warm kitchen cuts it. The bin is not a freezer, so melt water drains to the reservoir and the stored ice shrinks, which means the best use is fresh ice, not a stockpile.

  6. 06

    Support and price

    A major brand brings a manual, parts and a service line, which matter most in the second or third year, when a pump, a sensor or an auger motor is the likeliest thing to need attention and a seller's help desk is the thing you will actually use. The four machines differ more in finish and cleaning convenience than in ice quality, so weigh how much the extra cost of the Gallery or touchscreen model is worth to you compared with the plain EFIC228.

Detailed reviews

The 5 best frigidaire nugget ice makers, explained

01
Frigidaire touchscreen nugget ice maker, 33 lb, slate, sonic ice
33 lb per dayTouchscreen20 min cleanSlate
Check price on Amazon
Best for: Households that want the easiest routine cleaning.

The standout feature is housekeeping. A self-cleaning cycle that the maker says finishes in about twenty minutes removes the biggest reason people stop looking after a nugget machine: it takes too long. That one convenience makes it the easiest of the four to keep in good shape across a year of daily use.

The touchscreen panel is the second selling point, replacing a row of buttons with a tap interface that shows ice-making status. The machine makes up to 33 pounds a day of light, crunchy pellets, and the slate finish suits a modern kitchen. As with all auger machines the cylinder collects scale, which a flush cycle does not remove.

Compared with the Gallery 33 lb it leans on speed of cleaning and a screen rather than a metal-faced body. Descale every month or two, keep clearance around the vents and dry the machine if it will sit idle.

What works

  • Self-cleaning cycle of about 20 minutes
  • Touchscreen control panel
  • Up to 33 lb per day
  • Soft chewable sonic nugget ice

Watch out for

  • Cleaning cycle does not remove mineral scale
  • Louder and heavier than a bullet machine

Spec sheet

Daily output
Up to 33 lb
Control
Touchscreen panel
Cleaning
Automatic cycle in about 20 minutes
Ice type
Soft chewable sonic nugget
Finish
Slate
02
Frigidaire Gallery Smart WiFi nugget ice maker, 44 lb, Tuya app control
44 lb per dayWiFi app24H schedulingSonic nugget
Check price on Amazon
Best for: Heavy users and hosts who want remote start and scheduling.

This is the highest-output Frigidaire nugget machine in the data, at up to 44 pounds a day, and the only one with a smart layer. The Tuya-based app lets you start and stop the machine remotely, set 24-hour schedules and receive alerts, which suits a household that likes ice ready at a set time.

Scheduling is more useful than it sounds on a nugget machine, because the first batch takes several minutes and a full bin takes an hour or two. Starting the machine from your phone before guests arrive removes the wait. The 44 pound rating is aimed at gatherings and heavy daily use. The cost is more electronics in a countertop appliance.

Compared with the touchscreen 33 lb model it makes a third more ice and adds remote control, while the touchscreen model has the quicker cleaning cycle. Descale monthly, keep vent clearance and confirm that the machine works from its own panel if the Wi-Fi drops.

What works

  • Up to 44 lb per day is the top output here
  • Wi-Fi app with remote start and stop
  • 24-hour scheduling and alerts
  • Soft crunchy sonic nugget ice

Watch out for

  • More electronics to fail than a plain model
  • Larger and costlier than the 33 lb machines

Spec sheet

Daily output
Up to 44 lb
Connectivity
WiFi with Tuya app
Scheduling
24-hour ice schedules
Alerts
App notifications
Ice type
Soft crunchy sonic nugget
03
Frigidaire Gallery countertop nugget ice maker, 33 lb, grey, auto clean
33 lb per dayGallery seriesAuto cleanStainless material
Check price on Amazon
Best for: Buyers who want the Gallery finish and an automatic cleaning function.

Gallery is Frigidaire's upscale line, and this grey 33 pound model brings the name and a stainless material list to the nugget category. It produces crunchy, chewable nuggets and carries an automatic self-cleaning function, so routine flushing is built in.

The maker asks buyers to check dimensions and weight before ordering, which is a fair warning: nugget machines are tall and heavy for a counter. The Gallery name suggests tighter fit and finish than the plainer units, though the ice itself is the same soft nugget as in the cheaper models.

Against the touchscreen model it offers a premium body and a similar output, without a screen or a published cleaning time. Descale on schedule, give it breathing room and wipe the bin regularly. The same Gallery 33 lb machine is also sold in a navy finish with stainless trim, so treat color as a style choice and compare the two listings only on price and delivery.

What works

  • Gallery-line fit and finish
  • Crunchy chewable nugget ice
  • Auto self-cleaning function
  • 33 lb per day

Watch out for

  • No published cleaning time or screen
  • Premium name adds cost for the same ice

Spec sheet

Daily output
33 lb
Series
Gallery
Ice type
Crunchy chewable nuggets
Cleaning
Auto self-cleaning
Material
Stainless components
04
Frigidaire EFIC144 countertop nugget ice maker, 33 lb, gunmetal
33 lb per day10 to 15 minGunmetalCountertop
Check price on Amazon
Best for: Households that want ice soon after switching on.

The EFIC144 is the quickest starter in the group, with a maker claim of a first batch of nugget ice in about 10 to 15 minutes, helping keep up with ice needs. It produces up to 33 pounds a day, matching the other models, in a gunmetal finish meant to impress guests.

The starting time comes from a cold machine, and later batches settle into the steady pace. For a household that decides at the last minute that it wants iced coffee, a faster first batch is a real convenience, and the countertop size suits most kitchens. The listing gives fewer details than the touchscreen model on cleaning.

Compared with the EFIC228 it starts faster and looks more modern. Descale monthly, check vent clearance and dry the machine before storage.

What works

  • First batch in about 10 to 15 minutes
  • Up to 33 lb per day
  • Gunmetal finish
  • Standard countertop size

Watch out for

  • Fewer published cleaning details
  • Same output as cheaper models

Spec sheet

Model
EFIC144
Daily output
Up to 33 lb
First batch
About 10 to 15 minutes
Ice type
Crunchy chewable nugget
Finish
Gunmetal
05
Frigidaire EFIC228 compact nugget ice maker, 33 lb, metallic finish
33 lb per day15 min first iceCompactPortable
Check price on Amazon
Best for: Buyers who want Frigidaire nugget ice at the lowest price.

The EFIC228 is the no-frills nugget machine: a compact countertop body, 33 pounds a day and soft crunchy ice within about fifteen minutes of starting. The maker says it plugs into any outlet at home and can come along to a campsite.

The portability claim is practical for a machine of this type, since many nugget machines are heavy and awkward. It has no touchscreen and no published fast cleaning cycle, so you handle more of the upkeep yourself. The ice is the same as in the dearer models.

Against the EFIC144 it starts a little slower and costs less. Descale regularly, wipe the bin every two weeks and give the vents clearance on all sides.

What works

  • Compact countertop body
  • 33 lb per day
  • Portable and plugs into any outlet
  • Simple design with fewer electronics

Watch out for

  • Slower first batch than the EFIC144
  • No touchscreen or published cleaning cycle

Spec sheet

Model
EFIC228
Daily output
33 lb
First ice
Within about 15 minutes
Size
Compact countertop
Portability
Plugs into any outlet

Spec sheet decoder

What the numbers on the box really mean

The specs manufacturers lead with, translated into what they tell you about real-world performance.

Nugget ice

Soft pellets made by scraping and compressing a frozen layer from a cold cylinder. They are chewable and flavor-absorbing.

Watch forAll four machines here make it, so the real differences are elsewhere.

Lbs per day

A daily output rating in a cool room with cold water. Real output is lower in a warm kitchen.

Watch forFour of the five claim 33 lb; only the Gallery Smart claims 44 lb, so output separates one machine from the rest.

First-ice time

How long a cold machine takes to deliver its first ice. Later cycles settle into a steady pace.

Watch forThe EFIC144 claims 10 to 15 minutes, the EFIC228 about 15.

Self-cleaning cycle

An automatic flush that rinses the reservoir and lines. It does not remove mineral scale.

Watch forThe touchscreen model lists about 20 minutes.

Gallery series

Frigidaire's upper line, with tighter finishes and often more features than its base models.

Watch forThe Gallery name does not change the ice; check what you gain.

Methodology

How We Evaluated These Frigidaire Nugget Ice Makers

Cleaning convenience

We rewarded the touchscreen model's roughly 20 minute automatic cycle and the Gallery's auto self-cleaning function. A cycle that is easy to run gets run. We noted that none removes scale, so every machine here still needs a monthly or bimonthly descale, and we gave the Gallery Smart credit for alerts that can remind you.

Start time

We compared claimed first-ice times, from 10 to 15 minutes on the EFIC144 to about 15 on the EFIC228. Faster starts earned credit for spontaneous use. We treated the numbers as cold-start figures.

Build and finish

We looked at the Gallery's stainless materials and premium line, the touchscreen's slate body and the other two finishes. We could not verify fit and finish beyond the listings, so we weighted claims cautiously and gave little credit to marketing adjectives that no spec sheet backs up. Where two machines differ only in color, such as the grey and navy Gallery 33 lb listings, we treated them as one.

Size and portability

We considered the EFIC228's compact, portable design and the weight of the taller machines. Nugget makers are heavy, so portability scored. We noted the need to measure cabinet clearance.

Value

We compared output, features and price tier, noting that all four make the same ice. The plain EFIC228 scored for value and the touchscreen model for convenience. A premium name was credited only for what it adds.

Decision guide

How to Choose the Right Frigidaire Nugget Ice Makers

By Priority

SituationPickWhy
Easiest cleaningFrigidaire touchscreen 33 lb20 minute cycle
Premium finishFrigidaire Gallery 33 lbGallery line
Fast first batchFrigidaire EFIC14410 to 15 minutes
Lowest priceFrigidaire EFIC228Compact and plain

By Budget

SituationPickWhy
Lowest outlayFrigidaire EFIC228No frills
Low outlay, quicker startFrigidaire EFIC144Faster first batch
Mid-range convenienceFrigidaire touchscreen 33 lbScreen and fast clean
Premium finishFrigidaire Gallery 33 lbGallery series

Convenience vs Simplicity

Convenience

The touchscreen model and the Gallery add automatic cleaning, with the touchscreen's cycle taking about 20 minutes. They cost more and have more to go wrong.

Simplicity

The EFIC144 and EFIC228 are plainer, with fewer electronics, and rely on you to run the cleaning and descale.

Convenience for busy households and simplicity for light, careful users, with the Gallery Smart for anyone who wants remote start as well.

Kitchen Fit

SituationPickWhy
Modern slate kitchenFrigidaire touchscreen 33 lbSlate finish
Gunmetal or dark kitchenFrigidaire EFIC144Gunmetal
Stainless-leaning kitchenFrigidaire Gallery 33 lbGrey stainless material
Portable useFrigidaire EFIC228Plugs into any outlet

For Iced Coffee Households Specifically

Look for

A quick first batch, steady output and an easy cleaning cycle, since coffee drinkers run the machine daily.

In this comparison

The EFIC144 starts fastest for a last-minute drink. The touchscreen model makes the daily routine easiest.

When to Spend More

Spend more if

You will run the machine daily and want an easy cleaning routine. The touchscreen model repays in effort saved.

Save if

You use ice a few times a week and can descale by hand. The EFIC228 does the same job.

Ownership

Maintenance schedule

The upkeep that decides whether this machine lasts two seasons or ten.

TaskIntervalWhy it matters
Descale the cylinderEvery 1 to 2 monthsScale slows the auger and cuts output. A descaling cycle with citric acid or an approved nugget-machine cleaner takes it off.
Run the self-cleaning cycleEvery 2 weeksIt flushes the reservoir of residue. It slows biofilm but does not replace descaling, and a machine that runs often needs it often, so tie the cycle to a calendar reminder rather than your memory.
Wipe the bin and chuteEvery 2 weeksA damp bin grows film. A soft cloth and a mild cleaner keep it fresh, and the chute where ice drops is the spot that collects residue first, so give it an extra swipe.
Clear ventsMonthlyA nugget machine pulls room air across its compressor, and a film of dust there means more fan noise and fewer pounds of ice. A soft brush on the grille and a few inches of open space on each side keep the compressor cool and quiet, and it costs nothing.
Dry the machine when idleBefore storageStanding water grows slime. Drain the tank, wipe it dry and leave the lid open, then run a flush cycle with fresh water before the first use after a long break so the first ice is clean.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

How are the four Frigidaire nugget machines different?

They make the same soft nugget ice at the same claimed 33 pounds a day. The differences are finish, first-ice time and cleaning convenience, with the touchscreen model's roughly 20 minute cycle the standout.

Is nugget ice worth the extra noise and weight?

If you like chewable ice that absorbs flavor, yes. Auger machines are louder and heavier than bullet makers, so decide where to place the machine before you buy. Think about the cord, the water source and the distance to the place you pour drinks, since a machine in the wrong corner gets used less than one near the sink.

Does the self-cleaning cycle replace descaling?

No. The cycle flushes the reservoir but not mineral scale on the cylinder. Descale with citric acid or a maker-approved cleaner every month or two. A chalky film on the reservoir walls or a machine that sounds strained are signs it is overdue, and a descaled machine will usually recover most of its lost output.

How long until the first ice?

The EFIC144 claims about 10 to 15 minutes and the EFIC228 about 15, from a cold start. After that the machine settles into a steady pace. If you want ice sooner, switch the machine on when you start preparing the drinks, not when you want the first one, and keep the lid closed so the bin stays cold.

Can I take one camping?

The EFIC228 is described as portable and plugs into any outlet, but it is still a heavy machine, and a generator must be able to start its compressor. Let it stand upright for a few hours after moving it before powering on.

Does the bin keep ice frozen?

No. Melt water drains to the reservoir, so stored ice shrinks. Use the ice fresh or bag it and freeze it. Nugget ice melts faster than a solid cube because of its airy structure, so a drink poured over it chills quickly and then dilutes sooner, which suits a quick iced coffee better than a long cocktail.

Bottom line

The short version

Browse more frigidaire nugget ice makerson Amazon →
James Miller, Lead Machine Editor

About the author

James Miller

Lead Machine Editor, MachineFanatic

James Miller leads MachineFanatic's buying guides, turning spec sheets, manuals and owner feedback into clear verdicts on power tools, outdoor power equipment, shop machines and kitchen machines.

More from James →

Keep reading

Related guides